Insideness and Outsideness

 Buckminster Fuller in his book, Synergetics, discusses the concept of insideness and outsideness. He said there are four states you can have relative to a boundary:

1. Outside
2. Outside on the surface
3. Inside on the surface
4. Inside

insideoutside01a.jpg

This appears obvious, but it has interesting implications when we look at tetrads.

First, I want to look at Marshall McLuhan‘s Laws of Media tetrad. McLuhan described his tetrad as having two domains:

1. Figure
2. Ground

Retrieve and Enhance were Figure laws. Reverse and Obsolesce were Ground Laws. The question this left me with is which is Inside and which is Outside? I decided to look at other tetrads to see if they could provide an answer. This led me to look at the Zachman Framework focuses.

zachmansixtetrads.jpg

The Zachman Framework focuses all complement each other with their four perspectives. I decided to look at the Network focus for guidance:

1. ExtraNetwork
2. InterNetwork
3. IntraNetwork
4. Node

Node appeared to conform with Inside, IntraNetwork with Inside-Surface, InterNetwork with Outside-Surface and ExtraNetwork with Outside.

insideoutside02.jpg

I believe that Obsolesce correlates to Node, Reverse to IntraNetwork, Enhance to InterNetwork and Retrieve to ExtraNetwork. Therefore, Insideness was Ground and Outsidedness was Figure. That being the case I let it guide all further correlations.

insideoutside07c.jpg 

Here is Moffett’s Data Dimension:

insideoutside04.jpg

Here are the DIKW perspectives:

insideoutside03.jpg

As you can see the possibility of correlations between many tetrads is possible when different metaphors bring out the similarities.

Here’s Maslow’s Hierarchy recognizing that the physiological needs are not a social need:

insideoutside06a.jpg

As you can see with Fuller, McLuhan, Zachman, DIKW and Maslow there is an inside and an outside to their tetrads. Crossing the boundary between the two sides requires a transition in viewpoint that we do not always recognize. That boundary can be the difference between an open and closed society, between order and chaos, between fire and ice.

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Insideness and Outsideness”

  1. Singularity Chains « relationary Says:

    […] 10th, 2007 In my previous post I discussed Insideness and Outsideness.  Now I am going to discuss the boundary between the inside and the […]

  2. Insideness and Outsideness Revolution « relationary Says:

    […] Insideness and Outsideness Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Atoms and Associations Posted in Uncategorized. Tags: abraham maslow, belonging, communication, esteem, existential, generalizing, insideness, james moffett, outsideness, physiological, recording, reporting, safety, self-actualization, sensory-motor, theorizing, translating, Uncategorized. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: